Talk:Essay:Clan Naval Forces
Sarna News
- HEXTECH Review - Wave 3 Brings More Urban Options To Your Battlefield
- Your BattleTech News Round-Up For March, 2024
- Crashing 'Mechs With Jennifer Brozek, Author Of The Rogue Academy Trilogy
- Getting The Word Out With Rem Alternis, Catalyst Community & Marketing Director
- Bad 'Mechs - Yeoman
- Read more →
Not an Essay[edit]
For the record, I disagree with the move of this article to Essay. It doesn’t meet the criteria for an essay. I would rather describe it as a landing page. Frabby (talk) 12:48, 11 March 2023 (EST)
- I don't feel it fits any other place on the wiki either, but it has the startings of what could be an essay on the subject of Clan naval power.--Dmon (talk) 12:56, 11 March 2023 (EST)
About specific ships[edit]
Although the Michael Norman is mentioned in the text, the Long March and Noble House curiously are not despite being named in the same BattleSpace scenario. All three were supposedly destroyed in the Pentagon Civil War (but I agree with the possibility that the Michael Norman was perhaps later recovered and salvaged, to explain the stated numbers).
The Tripitz was an SLDF ship but there is nothing to suggest she became part of the Exodus fleet. The derelict was later found on the literal other periphery end of the Inner Sphere. So I’m unsure why it even gets mentioned here? Frabby (talk) 02:54, 12 December 2023 (EST)
- I haven't seen the March and Noble. They don't ring a bell, and I've read too damn much on these Warships for a year. I'll get my reading hat on...
- Tirpitz is only because the number is stated as surviving the Civil War (to my recollection without my books in front of me right this second). Tirpitz survived. The other ships survived. Was the Tirpitz included in that number? I don't think it discusses the numbers going on Exodus, but I see the issue. Mostly, I try to give benefit of a doubt on numbering these things, but I'll review and change if needed. Thanks for the feedback, though.
- edit: I removed the Triptz, as 3057R is clear it's less than a dozen EXODUS ships (switching between surviving Amaris and going on EXODUS can throw me sometimes) and the Tripitz has no relation to EXODUS and the Clans (even if it's a fun bit of flavor). Less than a dozen isn't a dozen, though, so we're still over on the count. I confirmed the Congress numbers and made it more explicit that they're counted as lost and what the Clan-era numbers would be vs just being a part of EXODUS and early SLDF-in-Exile time. Ocherstone (talk) 09:06, 12 December 2023 (EST)