Talk:2nd Kavalleri (Free Rasalhague Republic)

(Redirected from Talk:2nd Kavalleri)

Merge[edit]

Suggested Merge with 2nd Kavalleri (Rasalhague Dominion) doesn't seem appropriate and would only cause confusion for users attempting to research Free Rasalhague Republic units. Merge of 2nd Kavalleri (Ghost Bear Dominion) with 2nd Kavalleri (Rasalhague Dominion) made sense as it is the same unit under Clan Ghost Bear command, but this page should remain separate as a unit with a distinct history and faction identity under independent Rasalhague command before the Ghost Bear takeover; the formation of Free Rasalhague's 2nd Kavalleri predates the Ghost Bear acquisition of the unit and formation of the Rasalhague Dominion by several in-universe decades.--Gudrød Gudrødson (talk) 07:46, 4 July 2023 (EDT)

I agree with all the points you raised. The counterargument is that the wiki's policy is that we have only one page for a character, ship, or unit no matter how it evolved over time, and we list it with it's most current name as the page title. So units such as the Eridani Light Horse and Lexington Combat Group which have histories going back 400 years are all still covered together on the same page despite having different identities throughout the eras. In that sense, either no FRR units are merged or all of them are. Considering the differences in Clan vs IS command structure, and how BT originated with a 31st century POV on lore, the FRR gets a lot of pre-Clan invasion attention. I'm removing the merge proposal tag from the page since such a decision would affect all units simultaneously, and the discussion for it would go well beyond one unit's Talk page. Csdavis715 (talk) 08:21, 10 February 2024 (EST)