Difference between revisions of "Talk:Federation of Skye"
Sarna News
(resp) |
(thanks) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
:*Great stuff. I agree with respect to the redirects. --[[User:Scaletail|Scaletail]] 18:43, 19 February 2011 (UTC) | :*Great stuff. I agree with respect to the redirects. --[[User:Scaletail|Scaletail]] 18:43, 19 February 2011 (UTC) | ||
:*Agree, ''very'' well written article now. I also agree that the redirects are validated. For conversational purposes, however, if someone where to expand upon the rebellions, they could very well merit their own articles. In which case, a direct link to this main article would be warranted in the sections you crafted. I still want to read the entire article and I'll be making some minor edits, mainly to the refs. Great job, Wolverine.--[[User:Revanche|Revanche]] <sup>([[User_talk:Revanche|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/Revanche|contribs]])</sup> 19:29, 19 February 2011 (UTC) | :*Agree, ''very'' well written article now. I also agree that the redirects are validated. For conversational purposes, however, if someone where to expand upon the rebellions, they could very well merit their own articles. In which case, a direct link to this main article would be warranted in the sections you crafted. I still want to read the entire article and I'll be making some minor edits, mainly to the refs. Great job, Wolverine.--[[User:Revanche|Revanche]] <sup>([[User_talk:Revanche|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/Revanche|contribs]])</sup> 19:29, 19 February 2011 (UTC) | ||
| + | :: Thanks. My concern about the Skye Rebellions is this : With respect to the first two, there is incredibly little detail on the actual military units involved, where specific incidents took place, etc. What they DID publish, you can read here, because I can say without arrogance I used it all. With respect to the third rebellion, its been traditionally treated as a side-conflict of the [[FedCom Civil War]]. Personally, I'm hoping for another "Historical" sourcebook covering these issues. Maybe Era Report 3062 will have more on the second one. Who knows? | ||
| + | :: Also : Here's the big part - I want to merge this with the [[Federation of Skye]] article. Let's face it, when people say "Skye did this, Skye did that", they are talking about the Isle. The rest of the Federation was dragged along for the ride, including such worlds as [[Hesperus II]] and [[Solaris 7]]. At the same time, someone felt the Federation was deserving of its own article. So I could rename my "Isle of Skye" to "Federation of Skye", and merge the material on that one, but I wasn't sure if that would be prudent. [[User:ClanWolverine101|ClanWolverine101]] 03:34, 20 February 2011 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 23:34, 19 February 2011
Isle of Sky
Okay - I just finished the Isle of Skye. It was by far the longest, most difficult original article I have written yet. It may also be the most controversial, as I would humbly submit that all linked references to the Federation of Skye, Free Skye and the various rebellions (at least three) should redirect to this one article. No doubt we'll have some discussion on that. Nevertheless, I was as thorough as possible. Please give it a look and give me your opinion when you have a chance. Thanks. ClanWolverine101 08:13, 19 February 2011 (UTC)
- Great stuff. I agree with respect to the redirects. --Scaletail 18:43, 19 February 2011 (UTC)
- Agree, very well written article now. I also agree that the redirects are validated. For conversational purposes, however, if someone where to expand upon the rebellions, they could very well merit their own articles. In which case, a direct link to this main article would be warranted in the sections you crafted. I still want to read the entire article and I'll be making some minor edits, mainly to the refs. Great job, Wolverine.--Revanche (talk|contribs) 19:29, 19 February 2011 (UTC)
- Thanks. My concern about the Skye Rebellions is this : With respect to the first two, there is incredibly little detail on the actual military units involved, where specific incidents took place, etc. What they DID publish, you can read here, because I can say without arrogance I used it all. With respect to the third rebellion, its been traditionally treated as a side-conflict of the FedCom Civil War. Personally, I'm hoping for another "Historical" sourcebook covering these issues. Maybe Era Report 3062 will have more on the second one. Who knows?
- Also : Here's the big part - I want to merge this with the Federation of Skye article. Let's face it, when people say "Skye did this, Skye did that", they are talking about the Isle. The rest of the Federation was dragged along for the ride, including such worlds as Hesperus II and Solaris 7. At the same time, someone felt the Federation was deserving of its own article. So I could rename my "Isle of Skye" to "Federation of Skye", and merge the material on that one, but I wasn't sure if that would be prudent. ClanWolverine101 03:34, 20 February 2011 (UTC)