Difference between revisions of "Talk:Hanya No Cha"

(a bit disagree)
m (fixed link)
Line 2: Line 2:
 
:Accompanied with a section redirect, I would have no problem.--[[User:Revanche|Revanche]] <sup>([[User_talk:Revanche|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/Revanche|contribs]])</sup> 18:31, 6 July 2008 (CDT)
 
:Accompanied with a section redirect, I would have no problem.--[[User:Revanche|Revanche]] <sup>([[User_talk:Revanche|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/Revanche|contribs]])</sup> 18:31, 6 July 2008 (CDT)
 
::...which brings us back to the discussion we had at [[Policy Talk:Notability]]. Is she more or less important/notable than, say, [[Jerry Akuma]], [[Grig Griez]] or [[Joshua Wolf]] (all of whom have their own articles, and still are listed in [[Category:People]])? I don't see why she was taken out of that Category. I agree she's a minor charakter but hardly a not-noteworthy charakter. [[User:Frabby|Frabby]] 08:16, 17 August 2008 (CDT)
 
::...which brings us back to the discussion we had at [[Policy Talk:Notability]]. Is she more or less important/notable than, say, [[Jerry Akuma]], [[Grig Griez]] or [[Joshua Wolf]] (all of whom have their own articles, and still are listed in [[Category:People]])? I don't see why she was taken out of that Category. I agree she's a minor charakter but hardly a not-noteworthy charakter. [[User:Frabby|Frabby]] 08:16, 17 August 2008 (CDT)
:::She has zero face time. Heck, I didn't even know her name until you created this article. I don't even know if she's dead or alive in 3067. I think she may be a sort of middle ground that I alluded to in [[BattleTechWiki talk: Project Biographies#People * Minor Characters|the most recent discussion on character notability]] that suggests there may be more than two categories of characters. She may be a character of medium importance: still worthy of her own article, but not a major character. --[[User:Scaletail|Scaletail]] 08:30, 17 August 2008 (CDT)
+
:::She has zero face time. Heck, I didn't even know her name until you created this article. I don't even know if she's dead or alive in 3067. I think she may be a sort of middle ground that I alluded to in [[BattleTechWiki talk: Project Biographies#People & Minor Characters|the most recent discussion on character notability]] that suggests there may be more than two categories of characters. She may be a character of medium importance: still worthy of her own article, but not a major character. --[[User:Scaletail|Scaletail]] 08:30, 17 August 2008 (CDT)
  
 
::::I respectfully disagree with you, Scaletail, on her 'middle ground' role. I'd see her clearly as a minor character, until further developed. Even if she did get face time in an article, I think in my "movie poster" test, her actor would not make it. However, if she became a central character with action and/or dialogue that ''created'' a major story line, I'd gladly bump her from minor to major league. But, as much as I am loathe to admit it, maybe there is call for a middle category. She's definitely more important to the 'verse than, say, [[Rupert Masterson]]. --[[User:Revanche|Revanche]] <sup>([[User_talk:Revanche|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/Revanche|contribs]])</sup> 10:22, 17 August 2008 (CDT)
 
::::I respectfully disagree with you, Scaletail, on her 'middle ground' role. I'd see her clearly as a minor character, until further developed. Even if she did get face time in an article, I think in my "movie poster" test, her actor would not make it. However, if she became a central character with action and/or dialogue that ''created'' a major story line, I'd gladly bump her from minor to major league. But, as much as I am loathe to admit it, maybe there is call for a middle category. She's definitely more important to the 'verse than, say, [[Rupert Masterson]]. --[[User:Revanche|Revanche]] <sup>([[User_talk:Revanche|talk]]|[[Special:Contributions/Revanche|contribs]])</sup> 10:22, 17 August 2008 (CDT)

Revision as of 15:29, 17 August 2008

Since there is very little info, would anybody object if I move this to Capellan Confederation/Minor Characters? --Scaletail 18:04, 6 July 2008 (CDT)

Accompanied with a section redirect, I would have no problem.--Revanche (talk|contribs) 18:31, 6 July 2008 (CDT)
...which brings us back to the discussion we had at Policy Talk:Notability. Is she more or less important/notable than, say, Jerry Akuma, Grig Griez or Joshua Wolf (all of whom have their own articles, and still are listed in)? I don't see why she was taken out of that Category. I agree she's a minor charakter but hardly a not-noteworthy charakter. Frabby 08:16, 17 August 2008 (CDT)
She has zero face time. Heck, I didn't even know her name until you created this article. I don't even know if she's dead or alive in 3067. I think she may be a sort of middle ground that I alluded to in the most recent discussion on character notability that suggests there may be more than two categories of characters. She may be a character of medium importance: still worthy of her own article, but not a major character. --Scaletail 08:30, 17 August 2008 (CDT)
I respectfully disagree with you, Scaletail, on her 'middle ground' role. I'd see her clearly as a minor character, until further developed. Even if she did get face time in an article, I think in my "movie poster" test, her actor would not make it. However, if she became a central character with action and/or dialogue that created a major story line, I'd gladly bump her from minor to major league. But, as much as I am loathe to admit it, maybe there is call for a middle category. She's definitely more important to the 'verse than, say, Rupert Masterson. --Revanche (talk|contribs) 10:22, 17 August 2008 (CDT)